Informed Consent & Pregnancy Loss
Professor Jill Wieber Lens, the Dorothy M. Willie Professor in Excellence at the University of Iowa College of Law, visited Saint Louis University School of Law on Sept. 17, 2026, as part of the Center for Health Law Studies Distinguished Speaker Series. A leading scholar in reproductive health with a particular focus on the law and politics of pregnancy loss, Lens’s research examines how race, class and gender shape access to preventative health care and influence patient experiences and outcomes.
Her book, "Stillbirth and the Law," draws on her experience after the stillbirth of her son, Caleb, in 2017 and examines how federal and state laws contribute to the United States' stagnant stillbirth rate, shape birthing parents' experiences of stillbirth, and influence broader cultural understandings of pregnancy loss.

In her presentation, “Informed Consent & Pregnancy Loss,” Lens focused on the lack of awareness and communication surrounding miscarriage and stillbirth. She examined why pregnancy loss is often unexpected — despite being relatively common — and how misinformation can contribute to confusion, guilt and stigma for those who experience it. Through research on public perceptions, patient experiences, informed consent and prenatal education, Lens argued that pregnancy loss should be discussed more openly as part of routine pregnancy care. Rather than assuming information about miscarriage and stillbirth will unnecessarily frighten patients, she questioned whether failing to provide that information leaves patients unprepared when a loss occurs.
Lens began by examining how common misconceptions are about miscarriage in general. Jonah Bardos and others, in "A National Survey on Public Perceptions of Miscarriage", found that 55% of participants incorrectly believed that miscarriages occur in fewer than 6% of pregnancies, while 10% believed that fewer than 2% of pregnancies end in miscarriages. This misconception was more common among men, who were 2.5 times more likely than women to report that miscarriages are uncommon. The study also examined what participants believed caused miscarriages. Although genetic abnormalities of the fetus are the most commonly identified cause of miscarriages, participants also attributed miscarriage to stress, lifting heavy objects, past sexually transmitted diseases, previous abortion, and use of an intrauterine device. Other responses included getting into an argument, moderate exercise, intercourse during pregnancy, jealousy, punishment from God, and premarital sex. Lens used these findings to demonstrate that a lack of accurate information not only creates an abstract misunderstanding about pregnancy loss but can also lead people to believe that ordinary activities or personal choices cause miscarriages.
This misunderstanding becomes particularly significant when considering the experiences of parents who experience stillbirth, the loss of a pregnancy at or after the 20th week of pregnancy. Maureen C. Kelley and Susan B. Trinidad’s "Silent Loss and the Clinical Encounter" found that many parents did not consider stillbirth as a realistic possibility before it happened to them. One participant explained that she had skipped the stillbirth chapter in her pregnancy book because she did not expect it to apply to her.
Even participants with high-risk pregnancies reported that their healthcare providers focused on the possibility of premature delivery without discussing stillbirth. Lens used these experiences to illustrate the disconnect between the actual risks associated with pregnancy and what patients are told to expect. When patients are not informed about pregnancy loss beforehand, the loss can become even more unexpected and difficult to understand.
Research presented by Danielle Pollock and others also challenged the assumption that discussing stillbirth causes significant anxiety. In a study examining fetal movement and stillbirth education, 44.5% of participants said they would feel very calm or slightly calmer if their healthcare provider discussed stillbirth along with tools for monitoring fetal movement. Another 23.9% reported that they would feel neither anxious nor calm, while 27.1% would feel slightly anxious and only 4.6% would feel very anxious. These results suggest that most patients may not experience the level of distress that providers anticipate from discussing pregnancy loss. Instead, providing information could give patients a better understanding of their pregnancy and potentially help destigmatize conversations about loss. Lens also emphasized that miscarriage and stillbirth should be discussed together rather than treating them as fundamentally different topics within prenatal education.
Professor Lens further connected this lack of information to the concept of informed consent, especially in procedures such as cesarean sections. The American College of Gynecologists has stated that informed consent requires not only external freedom but also freedom from ignorance. If patients are not given accurate information about potential pregnancy outcomes, including miscarriage and stillbirth, they might not have all the information necessary to make informed decisions about their care. Lens identified several possible reasons why physicians might not routinely discuss pregnancy loss, including the perception that it is inevitable, the relatively low risk for an individual pregnancy, concerns about creating unnecessary anxiety, economic disincentives (particularly as it relates to the global billing typical to obstetric care), and political or cultural considerations. These explanations raise an important question about whether avoiding a difficult conversation truly protects patients or simply leaves them less prepared.
Lens explored the connection between misinformation and misplaced blame through a recent case between venture capitalist Cindi Bi and her surrogate, Rebecca Smith, discussed in the WIRED article "The Baby Died. Whose Fault Is It?" In this case, the surrogate was hospitalized after her water broke prematurely and the baby later died in utero at 29 weeks. Following the loss, Bi blamed Smith for the baby’s death and pursued legal action against her, relying in part on a contractual provision requiring a “well-baby that didn’t die.” The dispute highlights how pregnancy loss can become a question of fault when there is an assumption that someone must be responsible, despite the complex medical circumstances surrounding stillbirth. It also raises broader questions about the legal and contractual pressures placed on surrogates, including how contractual obligations can be used to assign blame for pregnancy outcomes and potentially hold surrogates responsible for losses beyond their control.
Overall, Lens’s presentation highlighted a gap between how common pregnancy loss is and how rarely it is discussed as part of routine pregnancy care. The research presented suggests that patients often underestimate the possibility of miscarriage and stillbirth and might also hold inaccurate beliefs about their causes. At the same time, evidence indicates that discussing these outcomes does not necessarily create the level of anxiety that providers expect. By incorporating accurate information about pregnancy loss into prenatal care, healthcare providers could better prepare patients for the realities of pregnancy while reducing misinformation, stigma, and misplaced blame. Lens ultimately framed the issue not as a question of whether pregnancy loss should be discussed, but whether patients can truly make informed decisions when an important part of the possible pregnancy experience is left unspoken.